Estimated electricity legs: losses and the fuel chain
Numbers checked against the live data on
Most electricity publishers print one number per kilowatt-hour: the emissions of generating it. A delivered kilowatt-hour costs more than that. Some of the power is lost in the wires before it reaches your meter, and the fuel the plants burn had to be extracted, refined and transported first. Where a publisher prints those legs, factor search serves them as published. Where a publisher prints generation only, open-climate.ai adds the missing legs, computed by a stated rule from the publisher's own generation value and from public statistics, and marks every one of them as an estimate. This page says what the legs are, how each is computed, what they are worth, and how to leave them out.
The three legs#
| Leg | system_boundary |
What it covers | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Losses | transmission_distribution |
The generation emissions of the electricity lost between the plant and the meter. | The location-based generation value times k, where k = L / (1 - L) and L is the share of generated electricity the grid loses. |
| Fuel chain | upstream_fuel |
Extracting, processing and transporting the fuel the plants burn (well-to-tank). | The generation value times the fossil supply-chain ratio of the mix it states, plus that mix's biomass share times the biomass supply-chain factor. |
| Fuel chain of the losses | transmission_distribution_upstream |
The well-to-tank emissions of the lost electricity. | The location-based fuel-chain leg times k. |
Where the publisher prints no delivered total either, open-climate.ai also sums a well_to_use total per mix: generation plus the three legs. Where both loss legs stand, they are first summed into a loss subtotal, the losses plus their fuel chain, which the total reads in their place. The subtotal carries the same transmission_distribution boundary as the losses; its key ends in //_sum//transmission_distribution, its co2e_origin is summed_from_children, and its two legs sit beneath it. Where the publisher prints a total, or prints one of the legs, that printed number stays and no estimate replaces it. A printed loss leg becomes a part of the loss subtotal, so that subtotal is the printed losses plus the estimated fuel chain of the losses, not a second estimate of the losses. Every leg lives on its own factor, beside the base factor, with the same activity, region, unit and reference year, and the same licence as the base.
How each leg is computed#
Losses. L is the share of the electricity entering the grid that is lost before it reaches users, taken from a statistic for the region. Per kilowatt-hour delivered, the lost electricity is k = L / (1 - L) kilowatt-hours generated, so the loss leg is the location-based generation value times k. The location-based value is the consumption mix where the publisher prints one, else the production mix. Losses are physical, so the same loss value is stamped on every mix of the factor and year, the market-based mixes and a green contract included. That is the rule of the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance, Appendix B: losses are reported with the location-based factor unless certificates were bought to cover them.
Fuel chain. For each fossil fuel, the ratio of its well-to-tank emissions to its combustion emissions is taken from the UK Government GHG conversion factors 2026: natural gas 0.1657, coal 0.17455, fuel oil 0.22056 (other fossil generation takes the fuel-oil ratio). The mix's ratio, r_fossil, is the average of the three weighted by each fuel's share of the fossil combustion emissions of the mix the value states, in that year. The shares are the composition the publisher prints for that mix where it prints one (AIB's residual and total supplier mixes), else the region's own generation mix. The fuel-chain leg of a published mix is its generation value times r_fossil, plus the biomass share of the same composition times 0.071 kg CO2e per kWh, the biomass supply-chain factor of co2emissiefactoren.nl for 2024, applied to every year. The nuclear fuel chain adds 0: no full-rights figure for it is served, and every description states that gap. Plant construction is not included.
A green contract. A certified renewable tariff burns no fossil fuel, so its fuel-chain leg is the biomass share of the region's renewable generation times the biomass supply-chain factor. Its loss leg is the location-based one, as above.
Fuel chain of the losses. The fuel-chain leg of the location-based value times k. It is stamped on every mix too.
Which year. A leg takes the statistic of its own reference year. Where the region has none for that year, it takes the nearest earlier year, and only where no earlier year exists the nearest later one. The year used is printed in the leg's description.
Where the inputs come from#
Each input is read from a ladder, and the first rung that resolves wins. The rung caps the quality tier the leg can reach, and names the reason it carries.
| Rung | Loss share L | Cap | data_quality_reason_normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| L0 | The publisher's own printed figures: a printed loss leg over its generation value, or a printed generation and consumption series. | medium |
estimated_from_regional_statistic |
| L1 | A statistic published for the region: Eurostat energy balances (32 European regions), DUKES (Great Britain), SFOE (Switzerland), eGRID grid gross loss by interconnection (US subregions), Energinet's electricity balance (Denmark's two price areas), and for the 99 countries and the Europe aggregate none of these covers, the U.S. Energy Information Administration's international series. | medium |
estimated_from_regional_statistic |
| L2 | The nearest broader region with a row, the hops recorded. | very_low |
estimated_from_broader_region |
| Rung | Fuel weights and biomass share | Cap | data_quality_reason_normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| U1 | The publisher's own composition of the mix where it prints one (AIB's residual and total supplier mixes), else the region's own generation mix: Ember (countries), the eGRID resource mix (US subregions), the ECCC national inventory (Canadian provinces). | low |
estimated_from_regional_model |
| U2 | The nearest broader region's mix, the hops recorded. | very_low |
estimated_from_broader_region |
A loss share is never computed from a factor in the catalogue, and no weight or ratio is tuned to match any published leg. Every parameter the examples below use, with its source, edition, retrieval date and licence, is on the parameters page.
A ceiling on the publisher's own figures#
At rung L0 the loss share comes from the publisher's own figures; where those are a consumption and a generation series, as for ECCC and EPPO, it is the gap between them. Where a region imports much of its power, that gap is mostly trade with its neighbours, not loss, and reading it as loss inflates every leg computed from it. So an L0 share above 20 % is not trusted: outside the U.S. Energy Information Administration's international series, the highest share in the loss statistics open-climate.ai holds is 17.3 % (Montenegro, 2015). That series runs higher in 26 regions, up to 60.5 % (Haiti, 2018), because it counts theft and unbilled use as loss; it is a statistic, not a publisher's own figures, so the ceiling does not apply to it. A leg value past that ceiling is still computed and kept, but it is rated problematic with the reason implausible_estimated_loss_share, and a problematic value is not served: factor search, the API and the open-data files leave it out. Today that holds back 60 values on 8 factors, all of them ECCC's Canadian factors: the losses, the fuel chain of the losses and the full-chain total over them, on Prince Edward Island in every year and on Quebec in 2015, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2023. A total over a held-back leg is held back with it. Where the factor's newest value is the one held back, as on Prince Edward Island, its description says why; Quebec's factor is described from its served 2024 value and does not name the years held back. The ceiling does not send the leg down to another rung: the leg is held back, not re-estimated from a statistic.
What the legs are worth#
An estimated leg is served at the worst of three tiers: the cap of its rung, the tier of the base value it multiplies, and the tier its own calibration error earns on the same scale as a publisher's stated uncertainty (how the tier is set). The calibration error is the worst symmetric error of the rule against the publishers who do print the leg, measured once on 2026-09-24 and never fitted.
| Rung | Compared against | Worst error | Served at best |
|---|---|---|---|
| L0 | No independent comparator: a publisher reproduces its own leg. | not measured | medium |
| L1 | DESNZ Great Britain 2023 and ADEME France 2008 to 2024, 18 rows | 86.2 % | low |
| L2 | 26 eGRID subregions re-estimated from the US share | 4.8 % | very_low |
| U1 | co2emissiefactoren.nl (Netherlands), co2emissiefactoren.be (Belgium) and DESNZ, 31 rows | 77.2 % | low |
| U2 | 13 Canadian provinces and 27 eGRID subregions re-estimated from their country's mix | 1191.4 % | very_low |
Watch out. The rule was set two acceptance gates before it was measured: a worst error of 15 % on the loss leg and a median of 20 % with a worst of 50 % on the fuel-chain leg. Both failed. The Belgian publisher's fuel-chain leg is 12 to 15 % of its generation value where the rule gives 19 to 21 %, and the French loss leg before 2024 is 13 to 15 % of generation where the Eurostat share implies 8 to 9 %. The rule ships as designed, with the measured error served in the tier, and open-climate.ai has not yet decided whether to narrow it. Treat a leg at
lowas an order of magnitude, not a measurement.
A total over estimated legs is graded by its parts weighted by their shares of the sum (how a total is graded): it never rises above the tier of its largest part and never falls below that of its weakest, so a small leg no longer drags a total down to the leg's own tier. Where it lands at its weakest part's tier, it takes that part's reason only where every part at that tier gives the same one; where the loss leg and the fuel-chain legs tie at low with different reasons, the total carries no reason and each leg's own reason says why. The loss leg copies the GWP set of the location-based value it scales, which on a residual or green base need not be the base's own; the two fuel-chain legs are AR5, the vintage of their ratios, so a total over an AR6 base carries a mixed vintage (GWP values).
Licences#
Two rules, one for each side.
- Inputs. A statistic is used only where its licence grants all five rights, with no condition beyond credit, stating changes, no endorsement and notifying the publisher (five questions per licence). Ten inputs pass: Eurostat, DUKES, eGRID (grid gross loss and resource mix), SFOE, Energinet, the U.S. Energy Information Administration's international series, Ember, the UK Government conversion factors, co2emissiefactoren.nl and the ECCC national inventory. Mexico's SENER loss statistic does not (non-commercial terms), so no loss leg is estimated for Mexico. Without a loss share there is no fuel chain of the losses either, so the Mexican publisher gets the fuel-chain leg only.
- Targets. A publisher's own generation value may be scaled unless its terms answer "no" or "ask" to modifying and combining the data. No published number is ever changed, so a term that only forbids altering the figures is met. The legs sit in the publisher's own release and carry its licence, its tier and its credit line, so they are redistributable exactly where the base value is, and never more.
The exports credit every input beside the publisher: the Open Government Licence statement for DUKES and the UK conversion factors, CC BY 4.0 for Eurostat, Energinet and Ember with the changes stated, the public-domain notice for eGRID and for EIA's international series, the opendata.swiss source statement for SFOE, the Open Government Licence Canada for ECCC, and co2emissiefactoren.nl.
Which libraries get legs#
| Library | Base mixes | Legs added | Why not the rest |
|---|---|---|---|
| ADEME (136 regions, 2014 to 2016) | production | all three, totals | the grids outside France print generation only; France's own mixes print their legs, which stay; Mexico gets the fuel chain only, as its loss statistic fails the input rule |
| AIB (34 regions, 2022 to 2025) | production, residual, total_supplier_mix, and the added green value of 0 | all three, totals | Iceland's 2025 generation is fossil free, so the fuel chain of its production and green mixes is 0 |
| CO2emissiefactoren.be (Belgium, 2018 to 2025) | residual and the added green value of 0 | none | prints its own fuel chain and total, which stay; they are what the fuel-chain rule is measured against (the tier) |
| CO2emissiefactoren.nl (Netherlands, 2020 to 2026) | residual and the added green value of 0 | none | prints its own fuel chain and total, which stay; they are what the fuel-chain rule is measured against (the tier) |
| CoM (55 regions, 1990 to 2021) | consumption | all three, totals | |
| DEA (Denmark, 1990 to 2024) | production | fuel chain, totals | prints its electricity per kWh delivered, network losses included and fuel chain left out, which stays; only the fuel chain is estimated, its biomass term lifted by the kWh generated per kWh delivered (1 / (1 - L), from the Eurostat loss share), and the total beside it sums the two; the climate- and trade-corrected series gets none |
| DEWA (Dubai, 2016 to 2025) | production | all three, totals | |
| DiXi Group (Ukraine, 2020 to 2023) | production | fuel chain and fuel chain of the losses, totals | prints a delivered total per voltage class, without its fuel chain, and its own losses, so no loss leg; the total beside its generation mix adds the fuel chain, the printed losses of the distribution-connected class and their fuel chain; marginal and fossil-fleet values are left alone |
| ECCC (14 regions, 1990 to 2024) | production | all three, totals | prints a delivered total without its fuel chain, which stays; the legs sit on its generation mix and their total beside it holds the whole chain; the losses, their fuel chain and the total are held back where its own figures imply a loss share above 20 % (the ceiling) |
| eGRID (28 regions, 2023) | production | all three, totals | marginal values are left alone |
| Ei (Nordic area: Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, 2011 to 2024) | residual and the added green value of 0 | fuel chain | prints a Nordic residual mix and no location-based value, so it and its green value of 0 get the fuel chain only, on Europe's generation mix (the area is not a country); no loss leg and no total |
| Electricity Info (United Kingdom, 2004 to 2023) | supplier_specific | fuel chain | prints one market-based figure per UK supplier and no location-based value, so it gets the fuel chain only, on Great Britain's generation mix; a supplier's 0 gets none, its renewable mix not being stated; no loss leg and no total |
| Energinet (3 regions, 2010 to 2025) | consumption, residual, and the added green value of 0 | all three, totals | Denmark as a whole prints a residual mix and no location-based value, so it and its green value of 0 get the fuel chain only; the two price areas get all three |
| EPA Hub (28 regions, 2026) | production | all three, totals | marginal values are left alone |
| EPPO (Thailand, 2000 to 2025) | production | all three, totals | prints a delivered total without its fuel chain, which stays; the legs sit on its generation mix and their total beside it holds the whole chain |
| GIR (Korea, 2021 to 2023) | production | fuel chain, totals | prints its electricity per kWh consumed (소비단), network losses included and fuel chain left out, which stays; only the fuel chain is estimated, and the total beside it sums the two; the per-kWh-generated figure (발전단) gets no leg |
| Google Cloud (27 regions, 2021 to 2024) | consumption | all three | no total yet: Google names no GWP set, and a total over a base on an unnamed set and legs on a named one is not summed; Hong Kong gets no legs (no loss statistic, no mix) and Mexico's 2024 value the fuel chain only (no loss statistic); the 2019 and 2020 life-cycle values get none |
| Green-e (27 regions, 2019 to 2023) | residual and the added green value of 0 | none | no location-based value to scale |
| HuellaChile (6 regions, 2015 to 2025) | production | fuel chain and fuel chain of the losses, totals | prints its own losses factor for every system and year, which stays; no loss leg is estimated beside it |
| ISPRA (Italy, 1990 to 2025) | consumption | fuel chain, totals | prints its electricity per kWh consumed, network losses included and fuel chain left out, which stays; only the fuel chain is estimated, its biomass term scaled by ISPRA's own ratio of its figures per kWh consumed and per kWh of gross generation, and the total beside it sums the two |
| K-ETS MRV (Korea, 2016) | production | fuel chain, totals | reprints GIR's grid figure per kWh consumed, network losses included and fuel chain left out, which stays; only the fuel chain is estimated, and the total beside it sums the two |
| MEE (38 regions, 2023) | production, residual, and the added green value of 0 | all three, totals | |
| MfE (New Zealand, 2010 to 2025) | consumption | all three, totals | one factor per boundary; the losses are estimated only where MfE prints none (2010, 2011 and the quarters of 2023 to 2025), and its printed annual loss leg stays |
| MITECO (Spain, 2007 to 2025) | residual and the added green value of 0 | none | held out: no location-based value to scale (below) |
| NGA (Australia, 2025) | residual and the added green value of 0 | none | its scope 3 electricity factors already print the fuel chain and the grid losses as one leg |
| NVE (Norway, 2019 to 2025) | consumption, residual, and the added green value of 0 | all three, totals | |
| Statistics Finland (Finland, 2000 to 2024) | production | losses, totals | prints a life-cycle value that already holds the fuel chain, so only the losses are added to it, with a total over both |
| UOS (Iceland, 2016 to 2024) | green, production, residual, and the added green value of 0 | all three, totals | Iceland's generation is fossil free, so the fuel chain of its production and green mixes and the fuel chain of the losses are 0 |
| UPME (Colombia, 2019 to 2024) | production | all three | no total yet: the SIN resolutions name no GWP set, and a total over a base on an unnamed set and legs on a named one is not summed; the legs sit on the inventory factor only, and the three combined margins, generation a project displaces, get none |
Four publishers with generation-only electricity are held out. MITECO prints no location-based value, so there is nothing to scale a loss leg from. ISPRA prints its own loss leg and a consumption total, and its only whole-grid generation series is per kilowatt-hour of gross output, a basis the total does not share. Japan's Ministry of the Environment publishes 1,514 retailer factors of which only 4 carry a location-based value; open-climate.ai excluded it. Brazil's Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation (MCTI) publishes its grid factor under CC BY-ND 3.0, which grants no right to adapt it, and a leg scaled from that factor, or a total summed with it, is an adaptation.
The green value of 0. Where a publisher prints a residual mix and no green mix for the same year, a market-based value of 0 for a green contract is added on the residual's factor, marked grid_mix_origin = 'assigned' and green_electricity_zero. That 0 is not an estimate: under the Scope 2 Guidance a certificate carries the emission factor of the plant that generated the electricity, which is 0 for wind, solar and hydro, the case it stands for. A certificate from a plant that burns fuel, such as biomass, is not 0 (see the conformance section below). A note on the factor says who added the 0 and names that case. Its loss leg and fuel-chain leg are not zero, as above.
Worked examples#
All values in kg CO2e per kWh. The published generation value is the publisher's; every other number is open-climate.ai's and carries the tier in the last column.
Belgium, AIB 2025#
Inputs: Eurostat's Belgian loss share for 2024 (the nearest earlier year), 4.0755 %, so k = 0.042487. For the production and green mixes, Ember's Belgian mix for 2025, in which gas is 63.6 % of fossil emissions and other fossil 36.4 %, so r_fossil = 0.18566; a biomass share of generation of 5.11 % and of renewable generation of 13.24 %. For the residual and total supplier mixes, AIB's own composition of each: coal 28.3 %, gas 65.5 % and other fossil 6.2 % of fossil emissions, so r_fossil = 0.17159 and 0.17160; a biomass share of 1.95 % and 6.17 %. The location-based value is the production mix.
| Mix | Generation (published) | Fuel chain | Losses | Fuel chain of losses | Total | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
production |
0.12186 | 0.12186 x 0.18566 + 0.0511 x 0.071 = 0.02625 | 0.12186 x 0.042487 = 0.00518 | 0.02625 x 0.042487 = 0.00112 | 0.15440 | medium |
residual (the default) |
0.17101 | 0.17101 x 0.17159 + 0.0195 x 0.071 = 0.03073 | 0.00518 | 0.00112 | 0.20803 | medium |
total_supplier_mix |
0.11413 | 0.11413 x 0.17160 + 0.0617 x 0.071 = 0.02397 | 0.00518 | 0.00112 | 0.14439 | medium |
green |
0 | 0.1324 x 0.071 = 0.00940 | 0.00518 | 0.00112 | 0.01570 | low |
The loss legs are low because the loss rung's measured error is 86.2 %, although its cap is medium; the fuel-chain legs are low by their cap. AIB's base values are medium (CO2 only), which the legs cannot beat anyway. The production, residual and total supplier totals stay medium: the generation value is about four fifths of each, so the legs' error, weighted by their share, leaves the sum at the generation value's tier. The green total is low, because its legs are the whole of it. Browse the base in factor search.
Norway, NVE 2024#
Inputs: Eurostat's Norwegian loss share for 2024, 6.289 %, so k = 0.067111; Ember's Norwegian mix for 2024, gas 58.3 % and other fossil 41.7 % of fossil emissions, so r_fossil = 0.18859; biomass 0.15 % of generation and 0.155 % of renewables. The location-based value is the consumption mix ("Klimadeklarasjon"). The green value of 0 is the one open-climate.ai added, since NVE prints a residual mix ("Varedeklarasjon") and no green.
| Mix | Generation (published) | Fuel chain | Losses | Fuel chain of losses | Total | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
consumption |
0.01185 | 0.00234 | 0.00080 | 0.00016 | 0.01515 | low |
residual (the default) |
0.53484 | 0.10097 | 0.00080 | 0.00016 | 0.63677 | low |
green (added) |
0 | 0.00011 | 0.00080 | 0.00016 | 0.00106 | low |
Under a residual mix the fuel chain adds 19 %. That is r_fossil, the UK supply-chain ratios weighted by the fossil emissions of Norway's own generation, applied to the whole residual value; NVE prints no composition of its residual, so the fossil content of the residual does not enter it, so the share is about the same over any base (20 % over the consumption mix). Under a hydro-backed green contract the delivered kilowatt-hour is 0.001, not 0.
California, U.S. EPA 2026#
Inputs: eGRID's grid gross loss for the Western interconnection in 2023 (the nearest earlier year), 4.1497 %, so k = 0.043294; eGRID's CAMX resource mix for 2023, coal 10.4 %, gas 87.2 % and other fossil 2.5 % of fossil emissions, so r_fossil = 0.16797; biomass 2.15 % and nuclear 8.02 % of generation. The eGRID 2023 factor for the same subregion takes the same inputs in the same year.
| Mix | Generation (published) | Fuel chain | Losses | Fuel chain of losses | Total | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
production |
0.18378 | 0.18378 x 0.16797 + 0.0215 x 0.071 = 0.03240 | 0.18378 x 0.043294 = 0.00796 | 0.00140 | 0.22553 | low |
The base is high and AR6; the legs pull the total to low, and its GWP vintage is mixed. Browse the base in factor search.
New Zealand, MfE 2024#
MfE prints a loss leg for its annual factor, 0.007523 against a generation value of 0.099360, so the loss share is the publisher's own: k = 0.075718 (rung L0, no statistic needed). MfE prints no loss leg for its quarterly values, which take the annual k of their year, nor for 2010 and 2011, which take the k of 2012, the nearest year it prints. Ember's New Zealand mix for 2024 gives r_fossil = 0.17440 and a biomass share of 1.77 %.
| Factor | Generation (published) | Fuel chain | Losses | Fuel chain of losses | Total | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Electricity used, 2024 | 0.09936 | 0.01859 | 0.007523 (published, kept) | 0.00141 | 0.12688 | low |
| Electricity used, quarter to June 2024 | 0.13459 | 0.02473 | 0.13459 x 0.075718 = 0.01019 | 0.00187 | 0.17138 | low |
The annual value keeps MfE's printed loss leg: an estimate is never minted where the publisher prints the leg. The estimated loss values, the quarters and 2010 and 2011, stay stored for a reporter who asks for that period, but the default view leaves them out: in every year it applies to, MfE's printed loss leg answers instead. The loss subtotal beside it reads 0.00893 for 2024, the printed 0.007523 plus the estimated 0.00141; it is marked as an estimate because one of its two parts is. The quarterly loss leg is medium, the L0 cap, since that rung has no calibration error; the fuel-chain legs are low, so the totals are low.
Conformance with the GHG Protocol#
The legs follow two texts. The Scope 2 Guidance (2015), Appendix B (pp. 96 to 97), has the end user report transmission and distribution losses in scope 3 category 3 with the location-based factor, unless certificates were bought to cover the losses. The Scope 3 Standard, category 3 (Table 5.5, p. 41) and its Technical Guidance (Table 3.1, p. 39) place the upstream emissions of purchased fuels and electricity, the fuel chain of the generation and of the losses, in that same category. So the loss leg is always location-based, and the fuel-chain leg follows the mix you report. An independent review of the method against those texts found it consistent on the substance and noted the following limits, each stated here rather than smoothed over.
- The Protocol never prints a zero. A certificate conveys the generator's direct emission rate (Table 7.1 criterion 1, p. 60; Table 6.3, p. 48), which is zero for wind, solar and hydro and not for biomass, whose CH4 and N2O stay in scope 2 (section 6.12, p. 57). The green value of 0 served here is the non-combustion case; a biomass-backed certificate is not 0, and the row cannot tell the two apart.
- A green value applies only to a reporter whose instruments meet the Quality Criteria. Criteria 2 to 7 are properties of your contract, not of the row; without such an instrument you report the residual mix, and where none exists the location-based factor (sections 6.2, p. 44, and 6.5, p. 46). Criterion 8 asks you to disclose the residual mix beside a green claim (p. 60; section 7.5, p. 65).
- The loss formula is the UK Government's form. k = L / (1 - L) is how the DESNZ methodology derives its loss factor (paragraphs 3.21, p. 29, and 10.13, p. 117). The Protocol's worked forms multiply consumption by L itself (Appendix B, p. 96; formula 3.3 of the Technical Guidance, p. 45), which is smaller by the factor 1 - L, between 4 and 10 % on the grids above.
- The per-fuel ratios are British. They come from DESNZ Table 5 (pp. 23 to 24): coal from JEC WTW v5 (2019), natural gas from Exergia, E3M-Lab and COWI (2015), fuel oil taken as DESNZ's diesel estimate. Applying them to another country's fuel supply is a representativeness deviation of the kind the Technical Guidance (p. 44) and the Scope 3 Standard (Table 7.6) ask you to disclose. DESNZ's Table 5 prints no nuclear fuel chain, hence the 0.
- GWP vintages. The ratios are AR5, which DESNZ has held for its well-to-tank fuels since 2023 (paragraph 1.18, p. 16); the biomass factor is co2emissiefactoren.nl's AR5 row for 2024, applied to every year. The loss leg copies the vintage of the location-based value it scales by k, not the base value's: on NVE's residual and green mixes the base has no vintage and the loss leg is AR5, NVE's consumption value's.
- The loss share is the statistic's total losses, theft and metering differences included, as Appendix B's endnote 1 (p. 97) allows.
Whatever you report, disclose the method: a reader of your inventory should learn that the loss and fuel-chain legs were estimated, from which statistics, and at which tier. None of this is published or endorsed by the GHG Protocol or by any of the publishers named.
How a leg is marked, and how to leave it out#
- On the factor,
is_estimatedis true, and so isis_derived, which it implies. A summed total whose parts include an estimate isis_estimatedtoo. In factor search the row carries the badge "Added by open-climate.ai" and its description is open-climate.ai's, opening with who added it and from whose data, then the method with the actual numbers, the assumptions, the cap and its reason, the sources with their licences, and a not-endorsed line. The API serves the same field,is_estimated. - The description is written in English, French and German, each from its own template with the same numbers, not machine translated. A summed total has one too: who added it, its parts and their sum for the newest year, why the loss leg is location-based under every mix, its tier, and the sources.
- On the value,
co2e_originisestimated_from_reference, one of six origins besidesource,computed_from_gases,summed_from_children,differenced_from_parentandapportioned_from_parent. It is never anything else on a leg, and a leg is neversource. data_quality_reason_normalizedis one of the three rung tokens above, and the tier is capped as the table says.- The green value of 0 is marked on a different axis:
grid_mix_origin = 'assigned', withco2e_origin = 'source', because it is the factor a wind, solar or hydro certificate carries under the Protocol, not an estimate. - The leg's key is the base factor's key followed by
//_est//and the boundary, and a total's key is the base factor's key followed by//_sum//and the target boundary, so a re-ingest of the base or of a statistic replaces the legs in place. Each value also keeps a manifest,source_record: the base value, the rung, the hops, every input with its snapshot and licence, the formula and the year used. It sits onemission_factor_valueand can be read over SQL, but neither the API nor the open-data files serve it; the description summarises it, naming each input with its value, year and source.
To use published numbers only, filter is_estimated = false in the open-data files or SQL. The API has no filter for it: every row it returns carries the is_estimated field, so leave out the rows where it is true. To keep the legs but see where they came from, read the description. In the files and SQL, is_derived = false is stricter: it also drops the totals summed from a publisher's own printed parts (parents, children, double counting).
Related#
- The parameters and sources behind the examples
- Estimated fuel legs: the supply chain before the burn, the same approach for a fuel whose publisher prints combustion only
- Market-based vs location-based electricity
- System boundaries
- Data quality ratings and the normalised tier