Market-based vs location-based Scope 2 electricity

Numbers checked against the live data on

Location-based and market-based are the two ways the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance counts the emissions of the electricity you buy. The location-based method multiplies your consumption by the average emission factor of the grid you draw from; the market-based method uses the factor of what you contracted for: certificates, your supplier's mix, or the residual mix when you hold no contract. A company with operations where such contracts are sold reports both totals, side by side.

Location-based vs market-based at a glance#

Location-based Market-based
What it reflects The physical grid where you consume the power The electricity you contracted for
Factor it uses A grid average: the production or consumption mix A certificate, a contract, your supplier's mix, or the residual mix
Signing a green tariff changes it No Yes, if the tariff meets the quality criteria
Same number for every consumer on a grid Yes No
Who reports it Every company with Scope 2 emissions Every company with operations in markets that sell contractual instruments
calculation_approach in the data location_based market_based

Two methods, reported side by side#

  • Location-based. It reflects the physical grid. Every consumer in the same country gets the same number, whatever tariff they signed.
  • Market-based. It reflects your purchasing choices. A contract backed by guarantees of origin can bring the number close to zero, and whoever buys no such contract picks up what is left over.

You report both totals, next to each other. They answer different questions, so you never add them and never swap one for the other inside a total.

Watch out. The two methods can differ by a factor of two or more for the same country and year. A location-based factor in a market-based inventory is not a small approximation, it is a different answer.

When the GHG Protocol asks for each#

The GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance (2015), an amendment to the Corporate Standard, sets three rules.

  • Location-based, always. Every company reports a location-based Scope 2 total.
  • Market-based, where contracts exist. A company with any operations in markets that offer contractual instruments (guarantees of origin, renewable energy certificates, supplier-specific tariffs) also reports a market-based total. This is dual reporting.
  • A hierarchy for the market-based factor. Use the most precise instrument you hold, in this order: energy attribute certificates such as guarantees of origin in Europe or RECs in North America; contracts such as power purchase agreements, where no separate certificate exists; your supplier's or utility's emission rate; the residual mix; and only when none of these exists, a grid average, disclosed as such.

An instrument counts in the market-based total only if it meets the Scope 2 Quality Criteria (Table 7.1 of the Guidance). In short, it must:

  1. carry the emission rate of the power it stands for;
  2. be the only instrument claiming that power;
  3. be tracked, and redeemed or cancelled on your behalf;
  4. be issued and redeemed as close as possible to the period you consumed the power in;
  5. come from the same market as your operations.

Three more criteria cover utility factors (based on delivered electricity, net of certificates retired for customers), direct purchases and on-site generation (the certificates go to you and no one else), and the residual mix: you use one, or you disclose that none exists.

Note. The GHG Protocol is revising its Scope 2 Guidance. Until a revised edition is published, the 2015 edition described here is the one that applies.

The grid mixes#

The data records the method in calculation_approach and the precise mix in grid_mix. Each mix belongs to exactly one method, and the pair is enforced, so a row can never claim a residual mix under the location-based method.

grid_mix Method What it is
production location-based The emissions of the power plants in the country.
consumption location-based The production mix adjusted for imports and exports.
marginal location-based The plants that respond to an extra unit of demand.
residual market-based What is left once every tracked green claim has been removed. The default when you hold no contract.
total_supplier_mix market-based The combined mix every electricity supplier in a country discloses: certificate-tracked supply plus the residual mix. A national average, not one supplier's product.
supplier_specific market-based One supplier's own product mix, as that supplier discloses it. Applies only if that supplier sells you your power.
green market-based A certified renewable tariff. Applies only if you hold that tariff.

In factor search, filter on the method with approach and on the mix with grid_mix, for example all residual mixes.

The residual mix#

A residual mix exists to prevent double counting. When a wind farm sells a guarantee of origin to one buyer, that buyer claims the low-carbon power. The same kilowatt-hours must then leave the pool shared by everyone else. The residual mix is that remaining pool, so it is usually higher than the grid average. It is the market-based factor for any consumption no certificate or contract covers, which is why the Scope 2 Quality Criteria ask for it.

The total supplier mix#

AIB publishes a second market-based figure per country: the total supplier mix, the mix every electricity supplier in the country discloses taken together. It is the certificate-tracked supply plus the residual mix, so it is a national average and not any one supplier's product. The data elects it as the default in Austria, Switzerland and the Netherlands, where AIB publishes no residual mix; in the other 31 countries it sits beside the residual mix as a sibling value.

Which library publishes which mix#

Library Method Mixes in the data
AIB market-based, with a location-based sibling residual as the default for 31 European countries, total_supplier_mix for 3; production beside it for all 34
DESNZ location-based consumption for the UK grid
MITECO market-based residual ("Mix sin GdO"), green (renewable GdO), and supplier_specific in 532 factors for Spanish suppliers
ADEME location-based production for 137 regions, consumption for 11
U.S. EPA location-based production for 28 regions

Counts are default top-level factors. These are the libraries these docs use for examples; other libraries in factor search publish grid mixes too, and the grid_mix filter shows them all.

A worked example: France, both methods#

One AIB factor carries both methods for a country: the AIB factor for France holds four values for 2025, one per grid mix, all for the generation stage and all fossil CO2 only.

grid_mix Method When it applies kg CO2 per kWh
production location-based Always, in the location-based total 0.01370
residual market-based Consumption no certificate or contract covers 0.01711
total_supplier_mix market-based A national supplier average, not your own contract 0.01402
green market-based Consumption covered by guarantees of origin that meet the quality criteria 0

Watch out. The value an AIB factor shows first is its default, the residual mix (the total supplier mix in Austria, Switzerland and the Netherlands): a market-based figure either way. The location-based production value sits beside it on the same page. Read the grid_mix before you copy a number into a location-based total.

A French office that used 100,000 kWh in 2025 and holds no green contract reports:

  • location-based: 100,000 × 0.01370 = 1,370 kg CO2;
  • market-based: 100,000 × 0.01711 = 1,711 kg CO2.

If it buys guarantees of origin for all 100,000 kWh, and they meet the quality criteria, its market-based total falls to 0. Its location-based total stays at 1,370 kg: the grid it draws from has not changed.

France's two numbers sit close together: its grid is mostly nuclear and low in fossil CO2 either way. Elsewhere the gap is wide. AIB's 2025 values, per kWh:

Country production (location-based) residual (market-based)
Norway 0.00569 0.43093
Sweden 0.00489 0.20856
Germany 0.30494 0.70147
France 0.01370 0.01711

Norway's power is almost all hydro, yet its residual mix is about 75 times its production mix: most Norwegian guarantees of origin are sold to buyers outside Norway, so a Norwegian consumer without a contract is left with attributes nobody else claimed.

A second example: the UK, two publishers#

Both factors below cover only the power generation stage (system_boundary = generation), so the boundary matches.

Location-based Market-based
Library DESNZ AIB
grid_mix consumption residual
kg per kWh 0.13096 0.28064
Measured as CO2e, all gases Fossil CO2 only
Reference year 2026 2025

The market-based residual mix is more than twice the grid average. A UK company with no green contract reports 0.28064 in its market-based total and 0.13096 in its location-based total, for the same meter reading. The gas basis explains almost none of the gap: DESNZ's CO2 alone is 0.12943.

Spain shows the other end of the range. MITECO's residual mix is 0.258 kg CO2e per kWh, and its renewable guarantee-of-origin factor is 0.0. The zero applies only to power covered by those guarantees. AIB publishes its own Spanish residual mix too, at 0.23828 kg CO2: two publishers, two methods of building the residual, two numbers. Pick one and say which.

What the grid factor leaves out#

A generation row covers the power plants only. Losses in the transmission and distribution network, and the upstream emissions of the fuels the plants burn, are separate rows with their own system_boundary (transmission_distribution, upstream_fuel). DESNZ publishes all of them for the UK. Where a publisher prints generation only (AIB, EPA and eGRID among the public libraries), open-climate.ai adds the two legs and a total as marked estimates; Estimated electricity legs gives the rule, the numbers and how to leave them out. Check the boundary before you add an upstream or losses factor, and read System boundaries for how the parts relate to the total.